An Open Letter To The Congregation Regarding The Upcoming Holiday

Under normal circumstances, in a few days we would gather together to celebrate the festival of Purim. We celebrate by reading together the megillah. It tells a timeless story for every generation about standing up and avoiding death.

Since, as we all know, the whole megillah is a long megillah, I will suggest this shortened version that I think today’s people of all beliefs can relate to.

Once upon a time, there was an incompetent ruler of a great land, largely indifferent to the needs of his people, whose legitimacy was questioned by many. We are introduced to him because he gets mad at his wife and decides to select a new younger and prettier one by having women engage in competitions to show off their beauty before a mass audience, and picks one that catches his eye.

The administration is super racist and seems to have as its central policy position that it should retain power, and everyone should bow down to it as often as possible. Otherwise feasts and honors seem to be its top priority.

A grave threat then is endowed with great potential power in the land. One strong-willed person did not follow proper protective procedures, and now the threat has been unleashed and spreads through much of the population. It threatens mass death in the future, but as yet has not done much. Many of the actions needed to prevent this are made illegal. Those who can project into the future and think even a tiny bit see great devastation, but it is not too late to fight back and prevent most of it.

One person, in particular, has information that needs to be better known and potentially the power to contain the threat before it is too late.

This person is implored to speak up. Alas, this person is silent, because the authorities had not given explicit permission to speak or even enter their presence. There was great fear that there would be grave social retaliation if social norms were broken.

Meanwhile, across the land, for three days, people were asked to help fight this tragedy by sharing their thoughts and prayers. This is the only thing that they are known to have done. As far as we know they at most took nominal actions to guard their own personal safety, but mostly carried on business as usual.

Finally, courage allowed this person to speak truth to power. The threat was out there, and those who foolishly and spitefully allowed things to get this far lacked the power to reverse that decision.

Luckily, it was not too late. The people were given permission to take action and fight back!

The people rose up, did battle and vanquished the threat for the time being. It was doomed to remain endemic and periodically attempt to kill us again.

Then they celebrated, power was passed to more competent administration that cared about the land and its people, and taxes were raised.

Thus, we continue to tell the story, so that we will always remember, never bow down or refuse to speak up or defend ourselves. So each year we have an excuse to gather, eat and be merry, to tell a one-sided story and during the telling boo the names of the political enemies that hate us and that we make no attempt to sympathize with or truly understand.

And in this year’s context, maybe, just maybe, don’t have large indoor gatherings of people to eat communal food in a crowded space, and instead do this at home in some fashion, perhaps with a YouTube recording if you’re not up to a full reading, engage in social distancing, wash your damn hands, stop touching your damn face, and if you are in a position to do more than that, do even more.

Happy Purim, everybody!




This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to An Open Letter To The Congregation Regarding The Upcoming Holiday

  1. Anonymous-backtick says:

    Okay, maybe this is a place I can finally get an answer to this question without having my comment deleted or being called a troll.

    When you say “the administration is super racist”, are you just referring to travel bans/immigration law enforcement, or is there something Trump’s done to actually hurt *citizen* minorities?

    • Eric Fletcher says:

      That sounds like a trollish request. If you are serious, please provide an example of the kind of thing a President could do that would make you, personally, more convinced that his administration was “Racist.”

      • Anonymous-backtick says:

        I did that in my first post. I just want an example of a policy that had negative effects on a racial group within the citizenry.

    • TheZvi says:

      I mean that Haman hates the Jews and tries to exterminate them, and the King tells him that he’s so in favor of this that he can keep his bribe money. It’s kind of the whole point of the story. I’m willing to call that super racist.

      As for the other story obviously being told, and the question you’re asking, I do not think you are trolling and I won’t delete anything. But I also am not about to argue what is and isn’t racist, or politics in any form really, in a comment thread on the internet, so you don’t get my answer beyond ‘I think that sentence clearly works in the context of the things this post is trying to do and is not misleading.’

      (I also passed on a bunch of more explicit Mordechai/Sanders parallels for this reason, even though I thought they were pretty funny.)

  2. Pingback: On R0 | Don't Worry About the Vase

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s